This is a tricky one, but not really.
The festival is over, many great encounters, late night conversations, some good films, and interesting talks. What more could you ask for? A prize? Hardly.
But there's the rub. The closing night left a rather bad taste in the mouth, as not only were the actual awards, hmm, political (though some good films in there) but the (remarkably) mis-managed range of awards missed an opportunity to give a nod and a wink to art, artists and the 'international' component.
This is NOT any accusation of corruption or deal making, it's just a huge disappointment with the scope of IMAGINATION and awareness of what a festival could be and what this festival in particular SHOULD have been, namely a sincere but modest open door - a first try - with a lot of encouragement and, of course, more attention to those close to home.
But what happened?
If you had found yourself in the closing banquet in the splendid Dwor Polsk, free food and drinks for all courtesy of TVP, and general rollicking good humour, you would have seen one table of dark dressed jury members and TVP luminaries (Translator's note: lampposts) and another, more alcoholized table, symbolically further down, of filmmakers and musicians.
There were no sour grapes, but a sense of wasted opportunity. the reason? The prizes.
With the exception of Agnieszka Holland (more later) the four jury members (all very nice and personable people) were ALSO producers of some of the films in competition. perhaps it's really inevitable in the first volet of such an undertaking.
How unfortunate, then, that three of the five prizes were given to productions overseen by jury members.
How many of the others have co-production deals I would like to know. Any information welcome.
Like Ricky Gervais might say, 'Are they having a larf?'
Go onto the Prix Visionica website for full details.
Fiction: produced by TVP
Documentary: produced by independent Swedish producer (!)
Theatre: produced by Polish independent producer
Music/dance: produced by Dutch company headed by jury member
intermezzo: independent Austrian producer
So far so good, you say... what's wrong with that?
Here it comes, a number of smaller 'special awards' were announced. A chance to give that nod and wink to those outside the circle (perhaps to the Israeli filmmaker who had flown from tel Aviv, or to the young Polish/german director who paid his own way there, or to the Finnish director who braved three days of strikes by SAS.. or...)
Polish Film Institute award to three (three!!!) films by arte - jury member is head of arte
another award to TVP Kultura
then an extra special small award (a cheque, actually) to a Russian independent producer
Jury member Alexandr Wlasow, of Telekanal Kultura, (a lovely bloke, by the way) presented an award to an (absent) Chinese filmmaker. Ah, international at last.
Surely these special awards (with or without cheques) should be used as teasers for the way the festival intends to move forward? It was a little queasy making to see the jury members walking around the banquet clutching 'their awards. It was a huge missed opportunity to step slightly out of the local framework.
Verdict: must try harder next time.'
Later in the evening, Agnieszka Holland came down and sat with the by now rather raucous directors and was funny and gracious.
Now it's Sunday. The festival is over. To quote My Dylan/Zimmerman again 'anyone with any sense had already left town'
So it goes.
See you next time.
In Berlin.